null
Not All Aquarium Rocks Are Created Equal

Not All Aquarium Rocks Are Created Equal

Posted by Jeff A on on 20th Nov 2025

Not All Aquarium Rocks Are Created Equal

When you’re building an aquascape or decorating a new tank, rock choice is more than just picking what “looks cool.”

Some stones are inert and simply sit in your tank without changing anything. Others slowly release minerals into the water, raising hardness and sometimes pH over time.

That can be really helpful in certain setups—and a big problem in others.

In the video on this page, Jeff from Pet Zone SD shows a super simple at-home test to find out if your rock is likely to change your water parameters.

? Scroll up and watch the video to learn the test step-by-step.

Why Rock Chemistry Matters for Your Aquarium

Rocks aren’t just decoration. They can interact with your water, fish, and plants, even if you don’t see it right away.

Inert Rocks

These are the “chill” stones that don’t noticeably affect your water chemistry. They’re ideal for:

  • Planted tanks and aquascapes

  • Shrimp tanks

  • Soft water setups

  • Any system where you want stable, predictable parameters

Mineral-Rich Rocks

These can slowly raise:

  • GH (general hardness)

  • KH (carbonate hardness)

  • Sometimes pH

They can be a plus in:

  • African cichlid tanks

  • Livebearer setups (guppies, mollies, swordtails, etc.)

  • Hard, alkaline water systems

The trick is knowing which type of rock you have before you build that dream layout.

The Simple Rock Test (As Shown in the Video)

In Jeff’s demo, he walks through an easy “toolbox” test you can do at home with a small sample or exposed surface of your rock.

You’ll see how to:

  1. Expose a clean area of the stone

  2. Apply a basic test solution / acid

  3. Look for a visible reaction that suggests the rock may release hardness into your water

It’s quick, repeatable, and something every fishkeeper and aquascaper should know.

? To really learn it, watch the video in this post and follow along with Jeff.

When a Non-Inert Rock Is Actually Helpful

A rock that changes your water isn’t automatically “bad.” It just needs to match the type of fish and setup you’re running.

Mineral-rich rock can help:

  • Support higher pH and hardness

  • Keep parameters more stable for fish that like mineral-rich water

  • Create a more natural environment for certain species

Think African cichlids, many livebearers, and fish from hard, alkaline habitats.

For most planted tanks, community setups, and aquascapes, hobbyists usually prefer inert rock so they can:

  • Dial in parameters with their own choice of tap water, RO, and remineralizers

  • Keep fertilizers and CO₂ more consistent

  • Avoid slowly rising hardness that is hard to control later

How We Approach Rock at Pet Zone SD

When we help customers choose rock for their aquariums, we pay attention to:

  1. Looks – color, texture, shape, and how it will scape in the tank

  2. Function – how it builds structure, caves, and hiding spots

  3. Water chemistry – how it might influence pH, GH, and KH over time

That third part is easy to overlook, but it makes a big difference in how smoothly your tank runs long term.

Try It With Your Own Hardscape

Before you build your next layout with:

  • New stones from a landscape yard

  • “Mystery” rocks from outdoors

  • A type of hardscape you’ve never used before

…take a couple of minutes to test it first.

? Start by watching the video in this post to see exactly how Jeff runs the test and what to look for.

Need Help Choosing Rock?

If you’re not sure which rock is right for your fish and plants:

  • Visit us at Pet Zone SD (Convoy District & Mid-City – San Diego)

  • Or browse hardscape, plants, and supplies online at PetZoneSD.com

You can always bring photos of your tank or rock and ask the crew—we’re happy to help you pick something that looks good and works with your water.